top of page

New York Notice of Claim: The 90-Day Deadline for Suing the City, the MTA, and Other Government Entities

Writer: BLITZ LAW GROUP
BLITZ LAW GROUP
8 hours ago
5 min read

You catch your foot on a broken section of sidewalk in March and break your ankle. You know you have three years to bring an injury claim in New York, so you focus on getting better.

If that sidewalk belonged to the City, you may already be on a much shorter clock. Before you can sue a New York government entity, you generally must serve a formal notice of claim within 90 days. Miss it, and the claim can be lost before a lawyer ever reviews your case.

This guide explains who the rule covers, where the notice goes, what it has to say, and what can happen if you're late.


New York City Hall with a gold statue on top against a clear blue sky, framed by bare trees.

What Is a Notice of Claim?

A notice of claim is a written notice, served on a government entity, telling it that you were injured and intend to make a claim. Under New York General Municipal Law Section 50-e, serving it within 90 days after the claim arises is a condition of suing in most cases.

It is not the lawsuit. It is a required first step, and it has its own deadline and its own rules for how it must be served.


How a New York Notice of Claim Works: Who It Applies To

The rule applies to claims against "public corporations," which includes the City of New York, counties, towns, villages, school districts, and public authorities. Where the notice goes depends on who you are claiming against.


Who you're claiming against

Where the notice goes

City of New York (streets, sidewalks, parks, city vehicles, NYPD, FDNY, sanitation)

The NYC Comptroller's office

NYC Transit Authority (subway and city buses)

The Authority or its designated agent, not the Comptroller

NYC Housing Authority (NYCHA)

NYCHA or its designated agent, not the Comptroller

Counties, towns, villages, school districts

The entity itself, under its own rules

State of New York

Separate rules, through the Court of Claims


Serving the wrong office can be fatal to a claim even if you meet the 90 days. Public authorities have their own governing laws, so the correct entity and method of service need to be confirmed for every case.


The Two Clocks: 90 Days and One Year and 90 Days

Claims against government entities run on two separate deadlines.


Deadline

What It Is

90 days

Serve the notice of claim, counted from the date of the accident

1 year and 90 days

Start the lawsuit (General Municipal Law Section 50-i)

2 years

Start a wrongful death action, counted from the death

3 years

For comparison: most claims against private defendants


Most people know the three-year rule. It does not apply to the City or the MTA.


What the Notice Has to Say

A notice of claim generally must state:

  • The name and address of each claimant and the claimant's attorney

  • The nature of the claim

  • The time, place, and manner in which the claim arose

  • The injuries or damages claimed

The location has to be specific. "A sidewalk in Brooklyn" is not enough, and a vague or incorrect description is one of the most common reasons these claims run into trouble.


What If You Missed the 90 Days?

You may still have a path, but it is narrow. Under General Municipal Law Section 50-e(5), a court has discretion to allow a late notice of claim. The request generally must be made within the one year and 90 day period for suing, and a court cannot extend that outer limit in most cases.

When deciding, courts look at:

  • Whether the government learned the essential facts of the claim within the 90 days, or soon after

  • Whether you have a reasonable excuse for the delay

  • Whether the delay substantially prejudices the government's ability to defend itself


Courts also consider factors like a claimant's age or incapacity. None of this is guaranteed, and many late applications are denied. The safest approach is to treat 90 days as a hard deadline.


After the Notice: The 50-h Hearing

Once the notice is served, a municipality can demand that you give sworn testimony about the claim before you file suit. This is called a 50-h hearing, after General Municipal Law Section 50-h. It is a formal proceeding, and what you say can be used later. Your attorney can attend with you.


Why Claims Against the Government Are Harder

Even with a timely notice, these cases are harder than claims against private defendants:

  • Prior written notice. For many street and sidewalk defects, New York City is generally liable only if it had prior written notice of the specific defect, with exceptions such as where the City itself created the condition. A pothole that has existed for months may not count if no one reported it in writing.

  • Evidence disappears. Conditions get repaired, and surveillance footage gets overwritten.

  • Procedural traps. The wrong office, a defective notice, or a missed hearing can end a claim.


None of this means these cases can't be won. It means every step has to be right, from the first day.


Five Common Scenarios

1. A fall on a cracked city sidewalk or pothole. The City may be responsible, and the notice goes to the Comptroller. First work out who owns the sidewalk, because in many cases the adjacent property owner is responsible instead, and a private owner has no 90-day rule. See our post on slip and fall accidents in NYC.

2. Hit by an MTA or city bus. The notice goes to the Transit Authority or its designated agent, not the Comptroller. See our post on NYC bicycle accidents, which covers a cyclist's case against the MTA.

3. Hurt at a city park or playground. The notice generally goes to the Comptroller, and the 90 days start on the day of the injury, even if the injury seems minor at first.

4. Struck by a city vehicle. A sanitation truck, a police vehicle, or another city vehicle brings in the notice rules. You may also have a no-fault claim, which has its own 30-day deadline. See our guide to the New York no-fault insurance claim.

5. Injured in a public hospital or NYCHA building. These have their own notice requirements. NYCHA claims go to NYCHA, not the Comptroller.


What to Do in the First 30 Days

  1. Get medical care and keep every record.

  2. Write down the exact date, time, and location. Take photos and, if you can, a pin on a map.

  3. Photograph the defect or hazard before it changes, with something in the frame for scale.

  4. Collect witness names and numbers.

  5. Report the incident to the relevant agency or authority and get a report number.

  6. Do not give statements to anyone representing the government without speaking to an attorney first.

  7. Call an attorney immediately. Don't wait to see how your recovery goes. The 90 days are already running.


Talk to Blitz Law Group, for Free

If you were hurt on city property, by a city vehicle, or on public transit, the first question is who needs to be served, where, and by when. We will answer it, and we handle the notice of claim and the case that follows. Learn more about our municipal liability practice.


The consultation is free, and you pay nothing unless we win.


📞 212.871.1300

📍 260 Madison Avenue, 8th Floor, New York, NY 10016


This article is general information, not legal advice. Deadlines and procedures vary by entity and can change, so confirm them for your situation. Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Comments


bottom of page